Why treating every moment like a sign from God might actually dull your discernment

You were praying about your next big move, asking God for a sign. Then a butterfly landed on your windowsill. You hadn’t seen a butterfly in weeks. Obviously, that meant you should quit your job, start your side hustle, and move to Nashville. Or at least it felt that way.

You sent a text and saw a triple number pattern. You had a conversation and someone said the exact phrase you journaled last night. You kept hearing the same worship song everywhere, even in the frozen food aisle. Confirmation? Coincidence? Or just the reality of being human with pattern-loving brains?

God can and does use signs. Scripture is full of moments where He speaks through creation, circumstances, and even donkeys. But there’s a difference between receiving a sign and searching for one in every mildly poetic moment. As you mature in faith, the goal isn’t to collect clues like a spiritual scavenger hunt. It’s to learn the sound of His voice.

Sometimes the real danger isn’t in asking for a sign, it’s in assuming everything is one.

Why We Want Signs So Badly

We live in a world addicted to instant clarity. We expect same-day shipping from God, and when it doesn’t show up by 8 p.m., we refresh our spiritual tracking info.

Signs give us a sense of control over the unknown. They make the waiting less scary. When we feel overwhelmed by options, directionless in our calling, or exhausted by uncertainty, signs feel like a shortcut. They offer clarity without the hard work. They feel personal, even romantic. A butterfly landing at just the right moment feels easier than discernment. A quote on your feed seems more divine than slowing down to examine your motives.

But signs are dangerously vague. The same “confirmation” can mean three different things depending on what you want. And that’s the problem — signs don’t always reveal God’s will. They often expose our bias. We interpret what we want to believe. When we don’t have peace, we grab at patterns. When we don’t want to wait, we manufacture meaning.

God can use signs. But when you rely on them like a spiritual Magic 8-Ball, you risk trading intimacy for impulse.

What the Bible Actually Shows Us

Yes, God gives signs in Scripture. But they come with clarity and relationship. Gideon wasn’t playing games with the fleece. He was terrified and wanted confirmation for a command he’d already received. And the star of Bethlehem? That was a literal astronomical event used to guide people already searching for the Messiah, not a vague coincidence, but a supernatural GPS for those seeking in reverence.

What we don’t see? People being led by random patterns. God leads by presence, not novelty. He speaks through Word and Spirit. Discernment grows from walking with Him over time, not decoding symbols.

Ironically, obsessing over signs often leads to less relationship, not more. You get caught up interpreting messages instead of hearing His voice. But God doesn’t want to keep you guessing. He wants to grow your discernment. You can’t do that if you’re waiting for an angel to show up in your group chat.

What to Do Instead

When everything feels like a sign, critical thinking fades. Suddenly your barista writing your crush’s name on your cup feels like a marriage prophecy. A traffic jam is divine judgment. A pastor posts about rest, must be a sign to call out sick. It’s funny, until it’s not.

You start reading too much into everything. People’s texts. Your boss’s tone. You spiritualize every inconvenience. But not every no is an attack. Some are just… no.

Faith isn’t passive. It’s thoughtful. Discernment isn’t about signs falling from the sky. It’s about testing desires, fears, and questions against God’s Word and character.

Put too much weight on signs, and you become easy to manipulate. Anyone — even the enemy — can fake a sign. If a single Instagram post can reroute your life, you're not being led by God. You're being led by the algorithm.

How to Actually Hear God

Start with what He’s already said, Scripture. It’s not trendy, but it’s clear. Then seek wisdom through prayer, community, and reflection.

God isn’t hiding His will. But He is more interested in forming you than fast-tracking you. If He answered every question with a sign, you’d never build discernment. If He confirmed every step, you’d never learn to walk by faith.

When He speaks, it grows trust. When He’s silent, it might be where the growth is.

So what do you do when you want a sign?

Ask for wisdom (James 1:5). Slow down. Examine your motives. Talk to someone who doesn’t just hype you up. Open your Bible before Instagram. Trust that God can guide you, without hijacking your Spotify or sending a prophetic Uber driver.

And remember: the biggest “sign” already came. His name is Jesus. Everything else is detail.

If this resonated with you…
Brightide exists to help you grow a clear mind and a grounded faith. Subscribe for short, smart, biblical insight delivered every week, free.
And if it helped you, share it with a friend. With your support, this community can keep growing.

[Join the newsletter at thebrightide.com]